Hello traders, hope you are all having a great time . I am on Tradingview for just over a year and I have see all the hypes posted. You guys remember some , 100 trades to nowhere, the 10k to a million account also to nowhere, etc. Just imagine a vegetarian, a steak lover and a raw food enthusiast getting together to plan the menu, that would be fun!!! Well we are about to have some real fun!!! Relax and enjoy the show, while it last! Hope you all have a good sense of humor.
Trade with care and don't fall prey to hypes. Thanks for your support.
評論
⋅
so around 9000 of you saw this chart and only 200 decide it's worth a like? OK let me know in the comment why you don't think it's not worthy. (want to hear from the 8800)
評論
⋅
that should read "why you don't think it's worthy" **
評論
⋅
I am not really looking for likes , I have 100k , i am genuinely interested what the community needs to see if i am able to offer such.
評論
⋅
If you can't say what is it you don't like ,they don't troll , you will be making a fool out of yourself it you think I need likes! with almost 100K , i believe it should be removed, to make things interesting again.
評論
⋅
*then*don't troll
評論
⋅
Guys I seriously want to hear from the critics, when you listen to those who disagree with you ,you learn. Or you can be stubborn and don't listen and then you don't learn. I know when I criticize stuff on tradingview I get blamed for being arrogant, I get called names etc. I once posted a chart called "trading pin bars are for dummies " oh boy that created an uproar, guess what ? many traders now don't use pin bars after they have listened -yes LISTENED to my arguments why it is dangerous. So I want to hear from you what is it you want me to offer and i will try , no promise , but i will try .
評論
⋅
Ok only two very constructive critics so far , i have taken notice and will , try to update all charts, I am not saying anyone is a troll so please don't get me wrong , I am asking for serious constructive criticism. If you have one please post . I am open today to learn for everyone. What i said is if you are going to post provocative comments , then don't post.
First of all, when you published your GBPJPY chart, your breakout level for sell was 159.90 and then 2 hrs ago you published another 4hrs chart saying "sell the breakout" with a different level (161.40 this time). Therefore I agree with the poster "sketchmaster" that you need to publish entry, exit, SL levels, trade active, trade closed etc. before the trade to be more trustworthy (please see "chartwatchers" in that sense).
Second of all, sometimes you publish ideas with both directions as was the case for GBPJPY. "Possible one more up or sell the breakout". From marketing point of view, it is a good strategy, win-win, but from reliability point of view, it is not good.
Third of all, as one of the posters says when the trade goes against you, all we have is silence. But when it is in right direction, fireworks. I can understand this, too. Because otherwise how are you going to sell $2000 course, right?
I can show you hundreds of examples that Wave Theory not working and I am sure you can show me the opposite. Important thing is that one needs to be objective, and if you are keen to do mentoring and earning a living from this (and until today, I saw many mentors earning more from mentoring than trading, and some even do not / cannot trade at all) you should show your audited/tested results on a real account with clear entries, stops and exits. Hope you take this as a constructive criticism from a veteran trader. And one side note; Less ego would help you better, IMO, as internet is full of sales people/traders like you. Just my two cents.
swolf00183
⋅
you nailed it.
swolf00183
⋅
I have the same observation as you. Its high time people realise.
anilmangal
⋅
Hi Blackeagle , thanks for taking your time to answer, 1) I do give stops, entry and take profit, but only in my trading room , Sorry, yes i have a trading room and it's free for my traders since i do not charge then a monthly fee to be there. I also do two daily webinars , where I do do live updates on trades (again sorry but it's only for my traders, some things have value) 2) noted I will post update on all charts, but like i said if a trader screens look the candle is moving and i am not in the trade , since there was no setup then i will ignore him , most traders use their OWN strategy so they don't need to be SPOON FED with with to buy or sell .The charts are posted to help you see my views , direction of trade and to compare with yours. I said one more up move then look for the sell . I don't see why that is confusing , but since you ask , it meant it will go up more but I am only interested in the sell. Until this point i love your criticism, then you venture into the mentoring program with a slight angle of jealousy, no one stops you from mentoring ? please do if you have something to teach, BTW I am one of the few who showed my life account on the platform , it's still up on YouTube so check it . And thanks for ad on the mentoring but the cost is much more than you mention , I and not cheep ! hope you love my humor.
alr14uk
⋅
You are being very defensive, Anil.
anilmangal
⋅
I believe I am answering , why 1) I don't give give stops and entry and 2) i noted that i will try to update all charts, where is the defense? I admit that I have a mentoring program (wish we wouldn't talk a lot about that since i don't need the ad, my work speaks for itself) and i corre him on the cost.
blackeagle
⋅
Thanks for the reply. I did not venture into the mentoring program for being jealous. I did it intentionally, because there are too many newbies around here. It was just a warning for them. Anyway, good luck with your future endeavors.
anilmangal
⋅
Thank you , I would be the first to warn everyone to be careful, i do it in all my webinars, as a matter of fact NOT EVERYONE gets into my mentoring program.
sketchmaster
⋅
Only a few words about the meaning of my post, in this list it is the no. 1)...
I actually didn´t mean an exact figure of entry, SLs and TPs, even though that would be nice. I totaly undestand, that this is reserved for people from your TR. Also, otherwise it would be too easy, where is the fun then... :)
The what I meant is "Trade Active", "Order cancelled" "Trade closed: stop reached" et cetera... Then I know, ok - I´ve lost this one, but he made it with profit...my mistake, or he didn´t enter, trade is not active, the original idea took a diferent turn, stop forcing a trends in chart where there are non (my biggest issue lately). :)
anilmangal
⋅
Ok thanks , will try to see if I can do all those follow up , Time might be a constraint, but i will try
Second of all, sometimes you publish ideas with both directions as was the case for GBPJPY. "Possible one more up or sell the breakout". From marketing point of view, it is a good strategy, win-win, but from reliability point of view, it is not good.
Third of all, as one of the posters says when the trade goes against you, all we have is silence. But when it is in right direction, fireworks. I can understand this, too. Because otherwise how are you going to sell $2000 course, right?
I can show you hundreds of examples that Wave Theory not working and I am sure you can show me the opposite. Important thing is that one needs to be objective, and if you are keen to do mentoring and earning a living from this (and until today, I saw many mentors earning more from mentoring than trading, and some even do not / cannot trade at all) you should show your audited/tested results on a real account with clear entries, stops and exits. Hope you take this as a constructive criticism from a veteran trader. And one side note; Less ego would help you better, IMO, as internet is full of sales people/traders like you. Just my two cents.